localnews.ie

Supreme Court to hear ESB and EirGrid appeal in Killross Properties land access dispute

By Fionn Kelly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court will decide whether the ESB board could authorise its chief executive to let individual officers serve notices seeking access to land for upgrading electricity lines.

The Supreme Court has granted the Electricity Supply Board and EirGrid plc leave to appeal a Court of Appeal judgment in their dispute with Killross Properties Limited. The determination was delivered on 19 June 2017. The application was brought by the ESB as plaintiff.

The ESB sought access to land owned by Killross in order to upgrade electricity lines. It served a notice on Killross under section 53(3) of the Electricity (Supply) Act 1927 and then sued for orders requiring access to be permitted.

Killross counterclaimed that the notice was unlawful because of a breach of fair procedures, a defect in the notice and an unlawful delegation of the ESB's power to serve it. The High Court rejected each argument.

The Court of Appeal, with Peart, Hogan and Cregan JJ sitting, rejected Killross's appeal on fair procedures and on the defective notice. It allowed the appeal on one aspect of the delegation issue. The ESB board had permitted its chief executive to authorise individual officers to perform statutory functions such as giving the notice. The Court of Appeal held that the legislation required the board to exercise that power itself.

The ESB argued that the provision at issue appears in similar form in many statutes governing State bodies. It said the point could affect very many of them, both for past measures and for their future working. The Supreme Court agreed that the issue raises a matter of general public importance, noting the potential for a widespread impact. Killross did not oppose leave, which the court described as a responsible attitude. It added that leave cannot be granted without the constitutional threshold being met.

The court also welcomed the ESB's engagement with the criteria for leave under the 33rd Amendment. It noted differences between that test and statutory certification schemes, but left those questions for a case in which they would be decisive.

Because the court is satisfied on the main issue, it also found it in the interests of justice to address whether the delegation point was properly before the courts. Leave is granted on whether section 9 of the 1927 Act, or the Act as a whole, permits the board to authorise its chief executive to exercise the power. It is also granted on whether that issue was properly before the High Court or the Court of Appeal.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal