localnews.ie

Kathleen Connelly Clare wind farm case goes to Supreme Court on An Bord Pleanála appeal

By Gráinne Nolan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Board is appealing directly from a High Court ruling that quashed its permission for a six-turbine wind farm near the home of Connelly, a Clare householder.

The Supreme Court has granted An Bord Pleanála leave to appeal directly from the High Court in a wind farm case brought by Kathleen Connelly. The determination was delivered on 14 June 2017.

Connelly is a householder in County Clare who opposed a wind farm near her home. The development was to have six turbines. Clare County Council refused permission, and the developer, McMahon Finn Wind Acquisitions Limited, appealed to the Board, which granted permission in June 2014.

On 8 November 2016, Mr Justice Barrett in the High Court quashed that decision. He held that the Board had not given sufficient reasons for its appropriate assessment or its environmental impact assessment. He said it could not generically incorporate the Inspector's report.

The High Court refused to certify the case for the Court of Appeal. The Board therefore sought a direct appeal. It says the ruling sets a very high threshold for reasons and conflicts with other High Court decisions.

The Board said that in 2014 it did not generally accept 229 of 1,509 inspectors' recommendations, or 15.4%. It also raised whether it must record separate reasons for deciding an appropriate assessment was needed.

Connelly accepts that the obligations are matters of general public importance. She says the law is well settled and that the Board is relying on an outlier. Neither notice party opposes the application.

The Supreme Court called the case self-evidently one of general public importance. It said the question is the degree of particularity needed in the Board's decisions. It granted leave on all the grounds proposed.

The Board and Connelly must each file submissions within 7 days. A case management hearing will follow in about 21 days, with a joint book of authorities.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal