The Supreme Court has granted the Minister for Justice and Equality leave to appeal a Court of Appeal ruling in a case taken by Yaswin Balchand, Chandrika Gopee and their young son. The determination was delivered on 14 June 2017.
The family challenged the Minister's refusal to renew their permissions to remain in the State. They said she should have considered their private and family life under Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights.
The High Court dismissed their judicial review on 4 March 2016. The judge held that people in their position had minimal or no private and family rights that required consideration, and that they could have applied from outside the State.
The Court of Appeal delivered its ruling on 15 December 2016, and the Minister then sought leave to appeal. The Supreme Court noted that this case is similar to, but not identical with, Luximon v Minister for Justice and Equality, decided just before it.
The family do not contest the Minister's application. They say the Minister should not be allowed to argue points that were not pleaded or argued in the High Court.
The Supreme Court found that two matters of general public importance arise. The first is whether, given the procedural history, the Minister may now rely on the issues she wants to argue.
The second is whether section 4(7) of the Immigration Act 2004 required the Minister to consider constitutional family rights or Article 8 rights in deciding the application.
The court gave the same directions as in Luximon. The Minister must file submissions within one week and the family must reply within two weeks after that. The case goes to case management in four weeks, and the two appeals will travel together.