localnews.ie

Danibye Luximon student immigration case goes to Supreme Court on Minister for Justice appeal

By Cathal Brosnan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Minister is appealing a Court of Appeal ruling that she must consider family and private life rights when deciding applications to change immigration status.

The Supreme Court has granted the Minister for Justice and Equality leave to appeal a Court of Appeal ruling in a case taken by Danibye Luximon and her minor daughter. The determination was delivered on 14 June 2017.

Luximon entered the State lawfully in July 2006 to study and was registered on "Stamp 2" conditions. In 2012 she applied to renew her permission and to move to "Stamp 4" status, which would allow long-term residence. The Minister refused.

The High Court quashed that refusal in 2015, and the Court of Appeal upheld the order on 15 December 2016. It held that the Minister must consider rights under Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights, and constitutional family rights, when deciding such an application.

The Minister argues that those rights arise only when deportation is considered. She also says Luximon had no permission in place when she applied. Luximon disputes that the Minister can now raise that point, because it was not argued in the High Court.

The Supreme Court described the case as almost self-evidently a matter of general public importance. It noted the Minister's submission that many similar student cases are waiting in the High Court immigration list.

The court set two questions for the appeal. The first is whether, given the procedural history, the Minister can rely on the issues she now raises. The second is whether section 4(7) of the Immigration Act 2004 required her to consider constitutional family rights or Article 8 rights.

The Minister must file submissions within one week and Luximon within two weeks after that. The appeal will travel with Balchand v Minister for Justice and Equality, and a case management listing is set for four weeks after the determination.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal