localnews.ie

David Walsh granted Supreme Court appeal over two-week contempt of court sentence

By Ruairí Dolan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court will hear one issue: whether fair procedures were followed in the Waterford Circuit Court before he was found in contempt.

The Supreme Court has granted David Walsh leave to appeal against a Court of Appeal decision that he must serve the rest of a two-week prison sentence for contempt of court. The determination was delivered on 26 May 2017.

The case arose at Waterford Circuit Court in May 2016. Walsh attended to make representations for his sister, who was a party to the proceedings but was not present. The judge told him he could not do so.

According to the determination, Walsh persisted and was warned he could be found in contempt. He continued to interrupt, and refused an offer of legal aid to obtain a lawyer. The judge found him in contempt, and he was sentenced to two weeks in prison after he refused to apologise.

He applied to the High Court for an inquiry into his detention under Article 40 of the Constitution. The High Court held that he had been in contempt but that the sentence was disproportionate, and directed his release.

The Court of Appeal, with Birmingham, Mahon and Edwards JJ sitting, reversed that decision in March 2017. It directed that he serve the rest of the term, with a stay of seven days to apply to the Circuit Court judge to purge his contempt. He did not do so and applied to the Supreme Court instead.

Walsh set out 23 grounds of appeal. The Supreme Court said none met the constitutional threshold of a point of law of general public importance. It granted leave because he represented himself, the case concerns personal liberty and contempt of court matters are of some general importance.

Leave is granted on one issue, namely whether the proceedings in the Circuit Court followed fair and appropriate procedures before he was found in contempt. The court said this does not mean such procedures were or were not followed.

At a sitting on short notice in May 2017, it also stayed the Court of Appeal order.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal