localnews.ie

Fabola Limited and Hughes estate refused Supreme Court appeal over solicitor negligence claim

By Ruairí Dolan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court refused leave after the Court of Appeal struck out the claim against solicitor Michael Cusack over delay in a Dublin property purchase.

The Supreme Court refused Fabola Limited and Helen Hughes, personal representative of the estate of Oliver Hughes, leave to appeal against a Court of Appeal decision, in a determination delivered on 25 May 2017.

Their action claimed professional negligence and breach of contract against solicitor Michael Cusack. It concerned his investigation of title to a property at Crossguns Bridge, Prospect Road, Dublin, which they bought in 2001 to develop as a licensed premises.

The High Court refused to strike out the action for delay on 25 January 2016. It found the delay inordinate and inexcusable but said the balance of justice favoured letting the case proceed.

The Court of Appeal disagreed in an ex tempore judgment on 27 February 2017. It struck out the proceedings, holding that prejudice to Cusack could be presumed from the long delay.

The applicants said they would be denied access to the courts. The Supreme Court said that argument could be made against any strike-out for delay. It found the Court of Appeal had applied well-settled principles to largely uncontested facts.

The court held that no point of general public importance arose and the interests of justice did not require a second appeal. It refused leave.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal