The Supreme Court has said it would extend time and grant Michael Rowan leave to appeal a costs order made in favour of Kerry County Council, if it has the jurisdiction to do so. The determination was delivered on 15 May 2017.
Timothy Mulvihill is a notice party in the case. The court will first hear the jurisdiction question before an expanded panel.
This was the second determination in Rowan's applications. In the first, the court refused him leave to appeal the High Court's refusal of a certificate for leave to appeal under section 50 of the Planning and Development Act 2000.
The court directed an oral hearing on his application to appeal the High Court's costs order against him. That hearing took place on 4 April.
The court found that time should be extended in principle. Rowan had intended to appeal in time and had brought an appeal that failed because no section 50 certificate had been obtained.
It said the argument that no certificate was needed for an appeal confined to costs was stateable, even though the court later took the opposite view.
The court also found that a point of general public importance had been raised. Rowan relies on the Aarhus Convention and European Union law, and says a costs order should not make his challenge prohibitively expensive. The court did not consider the merits of that argument.
The jurisdiction issue is whether the 33rd Amendment to the Constitution applies to a High Court order made before it took effect. When that order was made, no appeal was possible without a certificate.
The court said a panel of at least five judges should decide the question. Rowan must file revised submissions on it within two weeks of the determination. Kerry County Council must reply within a further two weeks.