The Supreme Court refused both John Spencer and Irish Bank Resolution Corporation Limited leave to appeal from the Court of Appeal, in a determination delivered on 26 April 2017.
Spencer sued the bank for negligent misstatement and misrepresentation over an investment in a fund to redevelop a London shopping centre. He had borrowed €1m from the bank to invest, and Stapleford Finance Limited, which later bought the loan, counterclaimed for the unpaid balance.
The High Court dismissed his claim and gave judgment to Stapleford. The Court of Appeal reversed that finding on the claim, holding that Spencer had proved he was induced to invest by specific statements made by the bank.
The bank asked to appeal only that finding on causation. It argued that the Court of Appeal had substituted its own view for the trial judge's. The Supreme Court called that argument misconceived, saying the Court of Appeal had examined the evidence of Spencer and the bank official who dealt with him.
Spencer separately sought leave, and an extension of time, to challenge an order giving him half of his High Court costs. The court said the costs decision appeared to be a standard application of established principles and refused leave.