localnews.ie

Thomas Kennedy refused Supreme Court appeal over brother's will in Tipperary probate case

By Saoirse Doyle

Historic decision · Decision date:

He sought to appeal a High Court ruling from February 2004, 12 years after the order was perfected, and the Supreme Court found no basis close to the constitutional threshold.

Thomas Kennedy has been refused leave to appeal directly to the Supreme Court over a High Court decision upholding his late brother's will. The Supreme Court delivered its determination on 19 January 2017.

The case began in the Circuit Court in Tipperary, where Mr Kennedy challenged the will of his brother Bartholomew Kennedy against Augustine Cunningham and Owen (otherwise Eoin) Harrahill. He argued that the will was not properly executed, that his brother was not of sound disposing mind, that he did not know and approve of its contents and that it was procured by undue influence. The Circuit Court rejected those claims and admitted the will to probate. Hardiman J., sitting in the High Court on appeal, dismissed Mr Kennedy's appeal on 20 February 2004.

Mr Kennedy's application for leave was made in 2016, some 12 years after the order was perfected on 10 March 2004. The Supreme Court said that raised difficult questions of time and of whether the 33rd Amendment applies to an earlier decision, but it did not need to decide them because the general threshold was not met.

Mr Kennedy said fraud had been pleaded. The Supreme Court said it had not, and that the proper way to allege that a court order was obtained by fraud is to bring new proceedings. It also said probate decides only whether a will is valid, not what assets the deceased owned, so his points about assets did not bear on the case. Leave was refused.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal