localnews.ie

Patrick and Angela McMahon refused Supreme Court appeal in Mars Capital mortgage case

By Fionn Kelly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The couple wanted to challenge a High Court order that upheld the substitution of one mortgage company for another in repossession proceedings over their family home.

The Supreme Court refused Patrick McMahon and Angela McMahon permission to appeal a High Court decision in a mortgage dispute with Mars Capital Ireland No 2 Limited, in a determination delivered on 7 April 2017.

The couple had objected to the substitution of Mars Capital for Springboard Mortgages Ltd as plaintiff in proceedings concerning a debt secured over what is understood to be their family home. The Circuit Court allowed the substitution, and the High Court dismissed their appeal against that order.

The McMahons told the Supreme Court that court procedures had been breached, that an allegation of fraud was not dealt with and that there had been overcharging. Mars Capital said the case involved only the application of well-established legal principles.

The Supreme Court described the matter as a straightforward procedural application in which one party transferred to another a right to enforce a debt. It noted that the mortgage appeared to have been redeemed in full in April 2016.

Because the appeal came directly from the High Court, the couple had to show exceptional circumstances. The court found none, and said the case raised no matter of general public importance and did not engage the interests of justice.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal