Interlink Ireland Limited, trading as DPD, has been granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in its franchise dispute with Cyril Reaney, Ita O'Regan and Travalon Limited. The determination was delivered on 30 March 2017.
The dispute arose from a franchise agreement of 22 December 1995 covering a courier depot area. The plaintiffs issued proceedings on 17 July 2008 and again on 8 July 2010, after DPD terminated the franchise with effect from 31 March 2010. The two actions were heard together.
DPD lodged €253,075 in court in January 2011 and a further €109,168.23 in October 2011, a total of €362,243.23. The High Court (Gilligan J.) gave judgment on 31 July 2012. Its awards totalled €356,200, and it refused interest.
The Court of Appeal gave judgment on 29 July 2016. It allowed the plaintiffs' cross-appeal on interest and varied the High Court order, so that judgment stood at €413,525.
The Court of Appeal had accepted that Order 22 lacked clarity and said it would be desirable for the Superior Courts Rules Committee to review it.
DPD argued that the question of how Courts Act interest is treated under Order 22 of the Rules of the Superior Courts, which governs lodgments, had not been considered before. The plaintiffs opposed leave, saying the interest issue was fact specific.
The Supreme Court held that the clear functioning of the lodgment procedure is a matter of general public importance. It listed seven issues, including how courts should use their discretion on interest and whether interest counts in the "amount awarded". They may be refined at case management.