localnews.ie

Brian Metcalfe refused Supreme Court appeal in medical negligence discovery dispute

By Aoife Loughran

Historic decision · Decision date:

The case centres on a request for documents about any professional negligence allegations made against Hendrik Lategan Smith in the five years before the assessment.

The Supreme Court refused Brian Metcalfe, a minor, leave to appeal in his medical negligence case against Hendrik Lategan Smith on 10 March 2017.

Brian sued through his mother and next friend, Nuala Metcalfe. He asked the High Court to order discovery of documents relating to any allegation of professional negligence made against Mr Smith. The request covered five years before the assessment at the centre of the claim.

The High Court (Stewart J.) refused the order on 25 January 2016. The Court of Appeal (Finlay Geoghegan, Hogan and Hanna JJ.) upheld that decision on 5 December 2016.

Brian argued that the High Court wrongly considered whether the documents would be admissible in evidence. He also argued that the Court of Appeal wrongly disregarded the fact that no replying affidavit was sworn.

The Supreme Court said the Court of Appeal had applied well-established principles to the facts of the case. It found no issue of general public importance. It also said a further appeal was not in the interests of justice.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal