localnews.ie

Peter Sweetman granted Supreme Court appeal over planning costs order

By Orla Quinn

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court will hear a direct appeal from the High Court on how far section 50B of the planning law protects objectors from costs.

The Supreme Court has granted Peter Sweetman leave to appeal directly from the High Court over a costs order in a planning case, in a determination delivered on 17 February 2017.

The Court said the case raises an issue of general public importance. It is the precise scope of the costs protection in section 50B of the Planning and Development Act 2000.

Mr Sweetman had challenged An Bórd Pleanála's decision to grant Eirgrid permission for works on an overhead line between Bellacorick and Castlebar. The High Court rejected that challenge and refused a certificate for leave to appeal.

The appeal concerns costs only. On 4 October 2016 the High Court heard the costs issue. On 18 October 2016 Mr Justice Hedigan awarded costs against Mr Sweetman in favour of the Board and Eirgrid. He refused a stay on the order and a certificate for leave to appeal on costs.

Mr Sweetman argued there is uncertainty over the limits of section 50B, which would ordinarily mean no order as to costs. He said the section should be read, if necessary, in line with EU law.

The Board said the section's meaning is clear and the judge's view matched earlier High Court decisions. Eirgrid said the environmental impact assessment part of the challenge was unmeritorious and the protection could be abused.

The Supreme Court said there is consistent High Court authority but no decision of its own. It said the question also touches EU law and the Aarhus Convention. A direct appeal was justified because the High Court had refused a certificate on costs.

Leave is limited to two grounds: whether the judge was wrong to find section 50B did not apply, and whether EU law required him to exercise his costs discretion differently.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal