The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by the Irish Aviation Authority against Padraig Higgins. The determination was delivered on 13 February 2017.
Mr Higgins sued for defamation over three e-mails. A then employee of the Authority sent them to the UK Civil Aviation Authority. Other Authority staff also received them. They followed an incident involving Mr Higgins while he flew a microlight aircraft in the United Kingdom.
The Authority offered to make amends under the Defamation Act 2009 by letter dated 25 May 2015. Mr Higgins accepted. The two sides could not agree the terms. He asked for a jury to assess his damages.
On 10 May 2016 the High Court (Moriarty J.) ruled that he was entitled to that. The Authority appealed. The Court of Appeal (Hogan J., Peart J. and Hedigan J.) dismissed the appeal on 4 November 2016.
The Court of Appeal said the question had never been decided before. It called the issue difficult, with no clear-cut answer. On balance, it held that the right to a jury was preserved.
The Authority argued that this was a matter of general public importance for defamation litigants. Mr Higgins disputed that. He said the Oireachtas could not have envisaged a defendant entering the process and then refusing to negotiate. He said it could not have envisaged a refusal to deliver an acceptable apology.
The Supreme Court agreed there was an issue of general public importance. It is whether a plaintiff can have damages assessed by a jury under section 23(1)(c). The alternative is assessment by a judge sitting alone.