John Keon, the tenant of an apartment in Salthill, County Galway, was refused leave to appeal by the Supreme Court on 19 December 2017. He had asked to challenge a Court of Appeal judgment of 4 July 2017.
The landlord's lender had appointed Mark Gibbs as receiver over the property, and the receiver wanted vacant possession to sell it. On 23 June 2015, a Tenancy Tribunal of the Private Residential Tenancies Board ordered Mr Keon to give up possession and pay arrears of rent and damages.
A tribunal finding can be appealed to the High Court on a point of law within 21 days, so Mr Keon applied for more time. In December 2015, the High Court (Baker J) refused, finding no good and sufficient reason and no stateable appeal.
The Court of Appeal (Finlay Geoghegan, Peart and Hogan JJ) dismissed his appeal. It found that he had put forward no arguable ground of appeal, so an extension of time would serve no purpose.
The Supreme Court said his application made barely any attempt to show that the constitutional threshold for leave was met. It held that the Court of Appeal had only applied the established rule that an arguable ground is a prerequisite to extending time.
It found that his other points, including those about the receiver, did not arise from that judgment. It also found there was no confusion over the date of the tribunal order, so the 21 days began on 23 June 2015.