The Supreme Court has granted Jonathan Fitzgerald leave to appeal his murder conviction, in a determination delivered on 15 December 2017, over the killing of Noel Crawford in Limerick on 18 December 2006.
Mr Crawford was shot dead shortly before 3am at the Crawford family home in O'Malley Park, Southill. On 7 February 2011, after a lengthy trial, Mr Fitzgerald was convicted of his murder.
A key prosecution witness told the trial that Mr Fitzgerald and two other men were in her home before the killing. She said two of them left with a shotgun, and that the three returned after she heard gunshots.
Late in the trial, the prosecution invited the defence to consider overnight whether to seek an accomplice warning about her evidence. The next day, no such application was made. A warning was given about another witness.
After the conviction, Mr Fitzgerald changed his legal team and appealed, arguing that the judge should have given a warning about her evidence. On 25 July 2016, the Court of Appeal (Birmingham, Sheehan and Mahon JJ) dismissed the appeal. It viewed her as an accomplice, but found no error because the judge was not asked for a warning.
The Director of Public Prosecutions opposed leave. It argued that Mr Fitzgerald had made an informed decision, with senior and junior counsel, not to seek a warning.
The Supreme Court found a point of general public importance: whether a trial judge must give an accomplice warning even where defence counsel has not requested one.