The Supreme Court has refused Joseph Kelly leave to appeal over his detention at Irishtown Garda Station, in a determination delivered on 8 December 2017. He had asked to challenge a Court of Appeal decision upholding the High Court's refusal of an Article 40.4 inquiry into the legality of his detention.
Mr Kelly was arrested on 6 November 2017 on suspicion of conspiracy to commit murder. He was held at Irishtown Garda Station under section 50 of the Criminal Justice Act 2007, which allows detention of up to seven days.
On 8 November 2017, the District Court was asked to extend his detention. A Detective Chief Superintendent gave evidence, but the arresting garda was not in court, and the member in charge was present without being called.
Mr Kelly's side argued that evidence from the arresting garda was needed before the extension could be granted. The District Judge took the view that this evidence was unnecessary and extended the detention. Two days later, Mr Kelly applied for the inquiry.
The Supreme Court said the 2009 amendments to section 50 did not appear to have been raised in any of the lower courts.
The court said a debate on his entitlement to relief could not be held without addressing those amendments. It added that this could not be done for the first time on appeal to the Supreme Court, and refused leave.