localnews.ie

Mark Finnegan granted Supreme Court appeal over arrest after absconding from prison

By Aoife Loughran

Historic decision · Decision date:

The court will examine when a delay by gardaí in arresting an absconding prisoner can make the arrest and later detention unlawful.

The Supreme Court has granted Mark Finnegan leave to appeal over his 2014 arrest for absconding from prison, on 8 December 2017.

Mr Finnegan was convicted on 19 November 2008 of allowing himself to be carried in a vehicle without the owner's consent. On 27 May 2009, he was sentenced to sixteen months in prison. He was transferred from Wheatfield Prison to Shelton Abbey Open Centre in July 2009. On 31 October 2009, he absconded and was declared unlawfully at large.

It was accepted that no steps were taken to arrest him until 2014. On 10 November 2014, he presented himself at Tallaght Garda Station. He was arrested and lodged in Wheatfield Prison.

The High Court found that his arrest and detention were not in accordance with law because of the delay. It treated the delay as four years and seven months. The Court of Appeal (Birmingham, Edwards and Hedigan JJ) allowed the appeal by the Superintendent of Tallaght Garda Station and the Governor of Wheatfield Prison. It directed that he be taken into custody to serve the rest of his sentence.

Mr Finnegan argued that the power to arrest must follow fair procedures, and that the authorities must act with reasonable expedition. He also challenged the way the Court of Appeal preferred one side's affidavit evidence. The respondents said gardaí are obliged to arrest an escapee, and that the State was unaware of his escape for much of the period.

The Supreme Court found an issue of general public importance. It concerns when delay by gardaí can make the arrest and detention of an absconding prisoner unlawful. It did not accept his argument based on the interests of justice.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal