Christopher McNamara, who was convicted of murder, was refused leave to appeal by the Supreme Court on 7 December 2017. He had asked to challenge a Court of Appeal decision of 3 March 2017 upholding the verdict.
He was convicted in the Central Criminal Court on 24 January 2014 after a ten-day trial, and sentenced to life imprisonment. The charge was the murder of James Boyce on 7 March 2011 at St Mary's Park, Limerick.
By the end of the trial, the only issue was whether the verdict should be murder or manslaughter. The trial judge defined murder for the jury but did not define manslaughter.
Before the Court of Appeal (Birmingham, Mahon and Edwards JJ), Mr McNamara argued that this left the jury without guidance on the distinction. That court found the definition of murder entirely accurate, and found the jury properly equipped to return manslaughter as the alternative.
The Supreme Court said the point was case specific and not one of general public importance. It said the jury had a binary choice, and that the judge's charge on murder put it in a position to decide accurately.
It also found that it was not in the interests of justice for the court to hear an appeal.