The Supreme Court has granted Anthony J. Fitzpatrick leave to appeal against a costs order made against him personally as liquidator of Ballyrider Limited, in a determination delivered on 5 December 2017. The Revenue Commissioners had asked the High Court to remove him as liquidator of the company, which is in voluntary liquidation.
On 21 July 2015, the High Court (Murphy J) agreed to remove him. The judge said he had not conducted the liquidation in an efficient or cost effective manner. She later ordered him to pay the Revenue's costs personally, because in defending the application he was solely protecting his own interests.
In July 2016, the Court of Appeal dismissed his appeal against removal, but allowed it in part on certain consequential orders. His appeal on costs was decided separately, in April 2017, by the Court of Appeal (Finlay Geoghegan, Irvine and Hogan JJ). It was common case that there was no finding of negligence, misconduct, personal unfitness or lack of integrity against him.
The Court of Appeal held that it was open to award costs against him personally, where his own interests were at stake. It reduced the award to 50% of the total costs, with the other 50% to be paid out of the company's assets.
Mr Fitzpatrick argued that an issue of general public importance arises over costs against a liquidator removed for reasons other than negligence or wrongdoing. The Revenue said the decision applied well established principles to the facts of the case.
The Supreme Court said costs questions will rarely meet the constitutional threshold. It found, however, that the liquidator's role is an important part of the public administration of company law, and that clarity on personal liability is needed. It said liquidators would have "greater certainty" whatever the result. He may pursue the grounds in section 6 of his notice.