The Supreme Court granted Aldi leave to appeal against Dunnes Stores on 4 December 2017. The case concerns trademark infringement. Aldi Stores (Ireland) Limited and Aldi GmbH & Co. KG sought leave after losing part of their case.
Aldi alleged that Dunnes infringed its trademarks in an advertising campaign. The High Court split the case into two modules. The first covered infringement. The second, on damages, has not been heard.
On 9 June 2015, the High Court (Cregan J) found that Dunnes had infringed the trademarks. It also found breaches of certain legislation. On 21 July 2015, it granted Aldi injunctive relief.
The Court of Appeal (Ryan P, Peart and Hogan JJ) upheld some of the findings of breach. It overturned the finding that Specific Comparison Labels and Shelf-Edge Labels were unlawful. It held that Aldi was therefore not entitled to an injunction. On 17 May 2017, it declined to order a re-trial. It awarded Dunnes 60% of its costs in both courts.
Aldi argued that the law affects any case where competitors use each other's trademarks in advertising. It said the Court of Appeal's reading was wrong and incompatible with European law. Dunnes said the case was limited in scope and that the Court of Appeal was correct.
The Supreme Court said an alleged error does not alone justify a further appeal. It found, however, that the case raises an issue of general public importance. Retail competition is governed by Irish and European rules. The court said their boundaries could be very important. It said it was reaching no view on the merits. Aldi may pursue the grounds in its notice, which the case management judge may refine.