localnews.ie

Sandra Maguire and four others granted Supreme Court appeal over committal warrants

By Donal Gilhooly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The five cases concern appeals from the District Court in criminal matters and whether a prison committal warrant must record that community service was considered.

Sandra Maguire, Thomas Brennan, Morufu Ademola Animashaun, Napoleon Silaghi and Lucian Marina have been granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court, in a determination delivered on 4 December 2017. The court will hear their appeals.

The Court of Appeal dealt with all five matters in a single judgment, Maguire v Governor of Mountjoy Prison [2017] IECA 142. Ms Maguire's case was against the Governor of Mountjoy Prison (the Dochas Centre), and Brennan's was against the Governor of Castlerea Prison. Animashaun's was against the Governor of Mountjoy Prison, and Silaghi and Marina brought theirs against Judge John O'Hagan and the Director of Public Prosecutions.

Two issues arise. The first is what a Circuit Court judge must do when hearing a criminal appeal from the District Court and the appellant does not appear. The second is whether a valid committal warrant must record that the judge considered the option of community service.

The Supreme Court said points of law of general public importance arise on both issues, and granted leave on that basis. Since the 33rd Amendment, leave requires either general public importance or that an appeal is necessary in the interests of justice.

The precise wording of the issues will be settled in case management. Granting leave decides only that the appeal can go ahead. It does not decide who is right.

The court observed that the issues would be "more efficiently determined" if two of the five cases were selected for hearing. If the parties do not agree, the case management judge will choose two. The other three will be adjourned until after judgment.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal