Sabrina Cummins, who was convicted of murder, was refused leave to appeal by the Supreme Court on 24 November 2017. She had asked to challenge a Court of Appeal decision of March 2017 that dismissed her appeal against conviction.
Her main ground concerned what happened after she gave evidence in her own defence, which was damaging to a co-accused. She then refused to be cross-examined, and the trial judge warned that he would treat this as a serious contempt of court.
He also said he would take the matter into account on sentencing if she was convicted of manslaughter. If she was convicted of murder, he would refer to it in his sentencing remarks. She then changed her mind, returned to the witness box and gave evidence.
Ms Cummins argued that the judge's statements were threats that pressured her to continue. The Supreme Court noted that the judge himself later described his remarks, somewhat colloquially, as "threats".
The court said a witness who refuses to continue or to answer proper questions would be in contempt, and that she had no right to refuse cross-examination. In continuing, it said, she was complying with a legal obligation and was not improperly pressured.
The remaining question was whether the trial was unfair as a whole. The Supreme Court said that was a matter for the Court of Appeal and raised no issue of general public importance.