The Supreme Court has refused Lucy Carr leave to appeal in her case against District Court judge Aeneas McCarthy, in a determination dated 24 November 2017.
The District Court proceedings have not yet been completed. Ms Carr can still contest the District Court proceedings on their merits, and appeal to the Circuit Court if she is unhappy with the outcome.
Ms Carr, who represents herself, had asked to appeal a Court of Appeal decision of May 2017. The Court of Appeal (Birmingham, Mahon and Hedigan JJ) had dismissed her appeal against a High Court order.
In February 2017, the High Court (Noonan J) refused her leave to seek judicial review of a District Court order. The District Court had refused to strike out the proceedings.
The High Court and the Court of Appeal considered that she was in essence seeking to review the substance of that District Court decision. The Supreme Court said both courts applied well established law.
It found that the application raised no issue of general public importance, and that an appeal was not otherwise in the interests of justice.