localnews.ie

Shillelagh Quarries refused Supreme Court appeal over stay on quarry closure

By Rory Hanlon

Historic decision · Decision date:

The company had obtained a lengthy stay on a High Court order to stop operating its quarry in south County Dublin, the court noted.

The Supreme Court refused Shillelagh Quarries Limited leave to appeal on 24 November 2017, in a dispute over how long it had to stop operating a quarry in south County Dublin.

In October 2015, the High Court (Baker J) held that the operation of the quarry was an unauthorised development. It directed that the operation cease, but invited submissions on a stay so the company could wind down. The case was brought by Michael McCoy and South Dublin County Council.

In January 2016, the trial judge allowed a two-month stay. The Court of Appeal then extended the stay in February 2016, pending the hearing of the company's appeal.

In May 2017, that appeal, which was limited to the period of the stay, was heard and dismissed. Within days, An Bord Pleanála refused the company's application for leave to apply for substituted consent, and the company began judicial review proceedings against that decision.

The company then asked the Supreme Court for leave to appeal the stay ruling. It pointed to Patterson v Murphy, an earlier High Court case on the same quarry.

The Supreme Court said that point had no significant relevance to the stay. It noted that the company had obtained a lengthy stay, and found no issue of general public importance and no other interest of justice requiring an appeal.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal