Eugene McCool has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in his complaint against the solicitor Colin Monaghan. The court gave its decision on 24 November 2017.
Mr McCool represented himself. He wanted to appeal a Court of Appeal decision of May 2017. It had dismissed his appeal against a ruling by the then President of the High Court, who had dismissed his appeal from the Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal. In June 2015 the Tribunal held there was no prima facie case for inquiring into Mr Monaghan's conduct.
Mr Monaghan had acted for the defendant company in proceedings brought by McCool Controls and Engineering Limited, of which Mr McCool was principal. His complaint concerned a motion to adjourn the case for mediation. It was listed at the end of the summer term in 2012 and heard in July 2012.
Mr McCool said Mr Monaghan was responsible for telling the plaintiff company's lawyer the motion would be heard at 2 o'clock. The case was in fact called at 11 o'clock. Both sides were represented, and the motion was refused.
The Supreme Court said there was no evidence that any wrong information was deliberate, and it had no adverse consequences. It found no point of law of general public importance and no interests of justice case for a further hearing.