Christopher Connors has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court over his conviction for handling a stolen bag. The court gave its decision on 24 November 2017.
He was tried before District Judge James Faughnan on 23 September 2014. His partner, who lived with him in the apartment where the bag was found, had pleaded guilty to the same charge. The investigating garda said he suspected Mr Connors had stolen the bag.
Mr Connors made two submissions for a direction at the close of the prosecution case. He said he could not be convicted of handling if the garda believed he had stolen the bag. He also said the prosecution needed evidence of a common design, because his partner had pleaded guilty. He complained that the judge rejected both without giving reasons.
Mr Connors brought judicial review proceedings to quash the conviction. The High Court (O'Regan J.) refused to quash it, and the Court of Appeal upheld that decision. The Director of Public Prosecutions is the second respondent.
The Supreme Court agreed that the arguments were very weak. It said the first confused garda suspicion with evidence of guilt, and the second was misconceived, because several people can be guilty of handling the same item without a joint enterprise.
The court said the Court of Appeal's judgment was based on well-established case law. Leave was refused.