localnews.ie

Eric Wansboro granted Supreme Court appeal over reactivated suspended sentences

By Aoife Loughran

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court will hear his appeal directly from the High Court, in a case about orders made under sections later found to be unconstitutional.

Eric Wansboro has been granted leave to appeal directly to the Supreme Court. The decision was delivered on 20 November 2017.

Mr Wansboro is challenging a High Court judgment of Ms Justice Faherty. The Director of Public Prosecutions and the Governor of Mountjoy Prison are the respondents.

His case arose from Moore & Ors v. DPP. There the High Court found that sections 99(9) and (10) of the Criminal Justice Act were invalid under the Constitution. Those sections dealt with the activation of suspended sentences.

Mr Wansboro said an order of the Circuit Court requiring him to serve re-activated sentences was itself invalid, in light of Moore. The High Court rejected his claim. He is appealing almost all of that judgment.

He argued that the case raised an important question. That question is how far orders made under the sections can stay in force. The State respondents said the case applied settled legal principles.

The Supreme Court agreed that the appeal raises an issue of general public importance. It said the precise circumstances in which orders made under impugned legislation can continue to have effect are of considerable importance.

A direct appeal also needs exceptional circumstances. Mr Wansboro said the Court of Appeal had already decided two cases on the same reasoning as the High Court. The Supreme Court accepted that an appeal to that court would be unlikely to succeed, so little would be gained from it.

It said the case was likely to look the same whether it came directly or after an intermediate appeal. It also said there was a considerable advantage in getting clarity quickly for all potential litigation in this area.

In principle, Mr Wansboro may pursue each ground in his notice of application. The case management judge may refine them.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal