localnews.ie

Patrick and Marie Cogan refused Supreme Court appeal in Elaine Newman eye injury case

By Orla Quinn

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Cogans wanted to overturn a Court of Appeal ruling that they breached their duty as occupiers when a glass door panel shattered.

The Supreme Court refused Patrick and Marie Cogan leave to appeal on 2 November 2017. They wanted to challenge a Court of Appeal judgment in favour of Elaine Newman, who lost her right eye in an accident at their home.

Ms Newman was 21 when a glass panel in an old wooden door shattered on 22 June 2007. She was at the house in County Meath, which belonged to her partner's parents. Her partner had tripped and put his hand through the glass. She sued the Cogans as occupiers under the Occupiers' Liability Act 1995, and damages were agreed at €200,000.

O'Neill J. dismissed her claim in the High Court on 5 December 2012. The Court of Appeal (Finlay Geoghegan, Irvine and Hogan JJ.) allowed her appeal on 16 June 2017. It held that the test was what a reasonably competent tradesman or amateur glazier would have done, and that the first defendant had not shown he met it.

The Cogans said the Court of Appeal had added a gloss to section 3 of the Act. The Supreme Court disagreed. It said no new issue of law arose, because the Court of Appeal had not added a gloss to section 3 but had applied it by reference to Wells v Cooper as persuasive authority, and an appeal court can apply the same test as a trial judge and reach a different result.

It found no significant error and no matter of general public importance. It did not need oral submissions.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal