localnews.ie

Simon Walsh refused Supreme Court appeal in dispute over uncle's will

By Cathal Brosnan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The court said the delay in lodging his application was not adequately explained and no point of general public importance arose.

Simon Walsh has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in a case over his late uncle's will. The court gave its decision on 2 November 2017. Mr Walsh was the defendant in his own right and as personal representative of his late mother, Christina Walsh.

The plaintiffs, Margaret Byrne and Elizabeth Quinn, challenged the will of Thomas Devey. Mr Devey was 81 when he died and had lived in psychiatric or nursing facilities for about 60 years.

The Circuit Court (Judge Linnane) held that Mr Devey lacked the capacity to make a will. It ordered Mr Walsh to return €19,505.50 to the estate. On appeal, Baker J. agreed on capacity but cut the sum to €16,000, to allow for his work in getting a reimbursement from the HSE under the Nursing Home Redress Scheme.

Mr Walsh applied directly to the Supreme Court, because there is no appeal from the High Court to the Court of Appeal in a case from the Circuit Court. He lodged his application on 24 May 2017, against a High Court decision of 21 January 2016.

The Supreme Court said the delay was not adequately explained. It said the High Court judge had given a full oral judgment and was not obliged to give a written one.

It also said he had raised no point of general public importance, and that two hearings were enough. Leave was refused.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal