localnews.ie

Olumide Smith refused Supreme Court appeal in employment disputes with Iquate Limited

By Eimear Byrne

Historic decision · Decision date:

The court said he had not identified a point of law and had already had three hearings on each matter.

The Supreme Court refused Olumide Smith leave to appeal on 2 November 2017. His case is against his former employer, Iquate Limited.

Mr Smith asked to appeal two High Court orders made by Noonan J. on 3 March 2017. One dismissed his appeal from the Employment Appeals Tribunal. The other dismissed his appeal from the Labour Court.

The first matter concerned the remedy available where the wrong version of his employer's name appeared on his contract. A Rights Commissioner directed Iquate to produce an amended contract but refused to order compensation.

The second matter was a complaint of racial discrimination. It failed before an equality officer and then before the Labour Court.

Both appeals to the High Court could only be on a point of law. Noonan J. noted that Mr Smith had not identified one, but he considered the merits because Mr Smith was a lay litigant.

The Supreme Court said Mr Smith had identified no point of law that met the constitutional criteria. It said he had three hearings on each matter, which exhausted his statutory right of appeal. Whether the Supreme Court has jurisdiction to hear a further appeal in such cases has not yet been definitively decided. The court said that question did not need to be decided in this case.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal