The Supreme Court refused Brian McDonagh leave to appeal on 26 October 2017. He wanted to challenge a Court of Appeal order of 6 February 2017 that struck out his appeal.
The case concerns a decision by An Bord Pleanála. Galway County Council and Apple Distribution Limited are notice parties.
On 17 October 2016 Humphreys J. gave Mr McDonagh leave to seek judicial review on some grounds but refused it on others. He did not seek a certificate of leave to appeal the refusal until later, and was refused on 30 January 2017. The Court of Appeal (the President, Irvine J., Kennedy J.) struck out his appeal because no such certificate had been granted.
In his Supreme Court application he said the case was of public interest. He said it related to a permission to destroy a 500-acre forest in the townland of Athenry, which he said went against national forestry policy.
The Supreme Court said he had not filed the extra papers its practice direction requires and had not replied to the registrar's letter of 22 May 2017. It said this alone would merit dismissal.
It also found that his narrow grounds, covering only part of the judicial review, did not raise a matter of general public importance. The court noted that he can still pursue the rest of his judicial review in the High Court.