The Supreme Court refused Patrick and Nuala Geoghegan leave to appeal on 11 October 2017. They had sued their former solicitors, Andrew Dillon and Patrick Mullins, formerly practising as Dillon Mullins, for professional negligence.
In 2004 the couple hired the solicitor to act in an action against eleven defendants. They believed those defendants were responsible for injuries and financial loss caused by the alumina processing plant at Aughinish Island. A plenary summons issued on 4 August 2004.
Some defendants were not served within twelve months. The High Court renewed the summons on 28 November 2005. On 8 May 2006, the ESB, one of the defendants, obtained an order from Johnson J. vacating that renewal.
The couple said the order applied to every defendant not served in time, and that the solicitor should have amended or appealed it. The solicitor said it applied only to the ESB.
On 18 June 2015 Kearns P. agreed with the solicitor. He dismissed the negligence claim and gave judgment for the solicitor for €42,138.40 plus costs. The Court of Appeal dismissed the couple's appeal.
The Supreme Court said the meaning of the order was a case-specific issue with no wider consequences. It also held an oral hearing before deciding the interests of justice did not require a further appeal. Leave was refused.