localnews.ie

Pól Ó Gríanna and 11 others refused Supreme Court appeal over windfarm planning permission

By Orla Quinn

Historic decision · Decision date:

The court said the applicants had not made out a stateable case that a rule against re-running arguments should not apply to them.

The Supreme Court refused Pól Ó Gríanna and 11 other applicants leave to appeal on 9 October 2017. They wanted to appeal directly from the High Court over An Bord Pleanála's permission for a windfarm.

The High Court judge, McGovern J., had refused them a certificate of leave to appeal. Cork County Council and Framore Limited are notice parties.

In an earlier case, Peart J. found the Board's environmental impact assessment flawed because it did not assess the turbines and the grid connection together. He sent the matter back to the Board, which then granted permission. The applicants challenged that decision too.

McGovern J. rejected their case. He held that their argument that the grid connection should have been in the original planning application was out of time. He also held that it breached the rule in Henderson v Henderson, because it could have been made in the first case.

The applicants told the Supreme Court that the rule should not apply because the developer had revised its plan. The changes included approximately 11.5 km of underground cabling and moving one turbine 50m.

The Supreme Court said those changes did not affect the point, as the grid connection was never part of the original application. It said EU environmental law might make the rule arguable in a suitable case, but the applicants had not made out a stateable case here. Leave was refused.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal