localnews.ie

Denis O'Brien granted Supreme Court appeal over Dáil committee decision

By Donal Gilhooly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The respondents did not oppose leave, and the court is considering case-managing his appeal with Kerins v McGuinness.

The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by Denis O'Brien over a decision of the Dáil's Committee on Procedure and Privileges. It granted him leave on 6 October 2017 to appeal directly from the High Court, bypassing the Court of Appeal.

Mr O'Brien sued the Clerk of Dáil Éireann and members of the committee: Sean Barrett, Joe Carey, John Halligan, Martin Heydon, Paul Kehoe, John Lyons, Dinny McGinley, Sean O Fearghail, Aengus O Snodaigh and Emmet Stagg. Ireland and the Attorney General are also defendants.

In the High Court, Ní Raifeartaigh J. dismissed his challenge to the committee's decision on the ground that the case was non-justiciable. The respondents intend to oppose the appeal, but they did not oppose the grant of leave.

The Supreme Court said it is no longer an appeal court designed to correct alleged errors by a trial court. For a direct appeal from the High Court, an applicant must show a matter of general public importance or that the interests of justice require an appeal. He must also show exceptional circumstances.

The court noted that the respondents appeared to accept the case meets the criteria of general public importance, the interests of justice or both. Mr O'Brien argued that any clarification of existing authorities should come from the Supreme Court. It also appeared that the case concerns a single issue of law, which further analysis in the Court of Appeal would be unlikely to narrow.

The court granted leave on the grounds in his notice of application, subject to possible refinement in case management. It listed the matter for mention on 9 October 2017, along with the directions hearing in Kerins v McGuinness, to consider whether to case-manage the two cases together.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal