The Supreme Court has refused the Health Service Executive leave to appeal in the case of Gill Russell, a minor who sued through his mother, Karen Russell. The determination was delivered on 1 February 2017.
Gill Russell suffered catastrophic injuries at birth on 12 July 2006. The HSE admitted negligence. He has cerebral palsy and needs 24-hour care.
The HSE wanted to challenge the Court of Appeal's ruling on the real rate of return. That rate is used to turn future losses into a lump sum. The Court of Appeal had set it at 1% for future care and 1.5% for his other future losses.
The Court of Appeal gave judgment on 5 November 2015. It largely upheld the High Court decision of Mr Justice Cross.
The Supreme Court said the HSE's complaint was fact-specific. It turned on the expert evidence in this case. The Court of Appeal had applied standard review principles.
The Court found no issue of general public importance. It also found no need for a further appeal in the interests of justice. Leave to appeal was refused.