James Mullen Senior has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in a dispute over the will of Elizabeth Mullen of Fahy, Clifden, County Galway. The Supreme Court delivered its determination on 8 July 2016.
Mrs Mullen died on 24 May 2012. Her will, dated 19 July 2004, left a plot of land of not more than half an acre to her grandson, James Mullen Junior. It named his uncle, James Mullen Senior, as executor.
The two disagreed over the meaning of the bequest. The High Court, in a judgment of Mr Justice Cregan on 31 July 2014, held that Mrs Mullen intended the land to be available to her grandson should he require it.
The Court of Appeal upheld that decision on 14 April 2016. It found that the words of the will were clear and that the land was meant to make up the site of his proposed new house, including adjacent amenity land such as a garden.
Mr Mullen Senior argued that the Court of Appeal had misapplied the principles for construing a will and should have changed the costs order. He also needed an extension of time to apply for leave.
The Supreme Court said the lower courts had applied well-established principles to the facts. It said he was seeking no more than a second appeal. It refused leave and did not need to decide the extension of time.