Patrick O'Connor has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in a dispute with Seamus Geaney over a consent judgment of €650,000. The Supreme Court delivered its determination on 29 June 2016.
Mr Geaney began proceedings in 2001 to recover a loan of Ir£500,000 plus interest. In July 2011, on the advice of counsel, the case was settled before Mr Justice Feeney on terms that judgment would be entered against Mr O'Connor for €650,000 and his counterclaim struck out. A consent order was made on 11 July 2011.
Mr O'Connor later asked the High Court to set aside that order, claiming the judgment had been obtained by fraud. Mr Justice Ryan refused his application on 7 April 2014, and Ms Justice Baker refused a further motion. She held that the issue had already been decided and that he could not show any flaw in how the consent was entered.
The Court of Appeal upheld that decision in a judgment delivered in March 2016. It held that he could not now set aside the consent judgment or have the case reopened.
Mr O'Connor argued that the Court of Appeal took too narrow a view of fraud and relied too heavily on the settlement. The Supreme Court found that the courts below had applied well-known principles that need no clarification, and that the issues turned on their own facts. It held that no matter of general public importance arose and that the interests of justice did not require an appeal.