localnews.ie

Patrick Lee granted Supreme Court appeal in US fraud extradition case

By Gráinne Nolan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court will hear a narrow question on whether offences committed in the United States count as committed in Ireland under the 1965 Extradition Act.

Patrick Lee has been granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in the Attorney General's case seeking his extradition to the United States. The Supreme Court delivered its determination on 29 June 2016.

On 23 March 2015, Mr Justice Edwards in the High Court ordered that Mr Lee be committed to prison to await the Minister's order for his extradition. The request came from the United States in August 2011, for a trial on 51 alleged counts, including 29 counts of wire fraud.

Mr Lee appealed to the Court of Appeal on a single ground. He argued that section 15 of the Extradition Act 1965 barred extradition where an offence is regarded under Irish law as having been committed in the State. The Court of Appeal gave its judgment on 20 April 2016.

That court found that no part of the offences was alleged to have been committed in Ireland. It said an offence committed abroad, over which Ireland claims extraterritorial jurisdiction, is not regarded as committed in the State. It relied on the Supreme Court's earlier decision in Attorney General v Pocevicius.

Mr Lee applied for leave to appeal. He argued that Irish laws creating extraterritorial offences include venue provisions deeming the offences to have occurred in the State, which would bring them within section 15. The Attorney General opposed the application, saying the Court of Appeal had interpreted the section correctly.

The Supreme Court criticised both sides' filings for reading like pleadings and said it is not an alternative court of appeal. It limited leave to three questions.

The first two are whether the Court of Appeal erred in distinguishing offences committed in the State from offences committed abroad over which Ireland claims jurisdiction, and in finding that the latter are not regarded as committed in the State for section 15. The third is whether the Pocevicius decision was correctly decided.

The appeal is confined to whether a finding for Mr Lee on any of those points would reverse the Court of Appeal's decision.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal