localnews.ie

Peter Sweetman Donegal quarry planning case goes to Supreme Court on State appeal

By Gráinne Nolan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The appeal, brought by Ireland and the Attorney General, is confined to whether Mr Sweetman's challenge was a collateral attack on an earlier Donegal County Council decision.

The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by the State in the planning case taken by Peter Sweetman over a quarry in County Donegal. The court granted leave to appeal in a determination delivered on 29 June 2016.

The State applied for leave. It is the second and third named respondents in the case, Ireland and the Attorney General, and An Bord Pleanála is the first named respondent.

Mr Sweetman had asked the High Court to quash a decision of An Bord Pleanála made on 4 November 2014 to grant substitute consent for the quarry's development. He also sought a fall-back declaration that parts of the planning acts of 2000 and 2010 are contrary to European law.

The State argued that the real decision had been made by Donegal County Council in June 2012. It said no judicial review was brought in time, so Mr Sweetman's challenge was a collateral attack on that decision. It applied to have the claim against the State struck out.

Mr Justice Hedigan found that the case was a direct challenge to the Board's decision. The Court of Appeal, in a judgment delivered by Mr Justice Mahon on 25 April 2016, agreed and dismissed the State's appeal. Its order was made on 11 May 2016.

The Supreme Court said the central issue is how to interpret the legislation introduced after a 2008 European Court of Justice ruling against Ireland on retention permission. It said the question is potentially of general importance and goes beyond the facts of this case.

Leave is confined to two questions. The first is whether Mr Sweetman's challenge to the Board's decision amounted to a collateral challenge to the earlier council decision. The second is whether, in light of that answer, the Court of Appeal's refusal to dismiss his application against the State should be overturned.

The State must file an amended notice of appeal limited to those issues, together with a notice of intention to proceed. Any question over whether it complies will go first to the case management judge.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal