The Supreme Court has refused Barth O'Neill leave to appeal in his dispute with the Revenue Commissioners over a tax assessment of €850,000. The decision was delivered on 10 February 2016.
Mr O'Neill, who brought the application himself, wanted to appeal a Court of Appeal judgment of 31 July 2015. That judgment dismissed his two judicial review appeals. The Attorney General was a notice party.
He had filed his 2007 return online and used the "expression of doubt" procedure. Revenue began looking at it in 2010. In April 2011 it issued the assessment. He argued Revenue had not decided within twelve months, as its online standards and internal code suggested.
The High Court refused him leave for judicial review. The Court of Appeal said Revenue had four years under statute to act and that its standards and code were not legally binding.
Mr O'Neill accepted that no point of general public importance arose. He relied on the interests of justice. The Supreme Court said the Court of Appeal had applied settled law. It praised the extensive work he had put in, but said his application did not meet the constitutional test.
The court also said it shared the Court of Appeal's view that Revenue "has not lived up to their aspired approach to customers" in his case. It said that did not lay a foundation for a further appeal. Leave was refused.