Waldemar Solowiow has been granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court against his conviction for the murder of Mary Ryan. The Supreme Court delivered its determination on 29 June 2016.
Leave was granted on one ground only. The conviction itself has not been overturned and the appeal has yet to be heard.
Mr Solowiow was convicted of murder after a trial before Mr Justice McCarthy and a jury in the Central Criminal Court. By the time of the trial it was accepted that he had killed Ms Ryan. The only issue was whether he should be convicted of murder or, because of provocation, of manslaughter.
He had first denied any involvement and gave an account, later accepted as untrue, of Ms Ryan being attacked by three people. He appealed to the Court of Appeal, which rejected his arguments about the trial judge's charge to the jury and upheld the conviction on 12 April 2016.
The Supreme Court held an oral hearing before deciding. It said it had two concerns: that no requisition had been made asking the trial judge to recharge the jury, and that the issue might be specific to the facts of the case.
The court was satisfied that the point is potentially of general application. Mr Solowiow's lawyers will argue that a jury should be told that early lies to gardaí are not themselves proof of guilt of murder rather than manslaughter. They say such lies go to his credibility and can be weighed in deciding whether the prosecution has ruled out provocation.
The court noted that there is no Irish authority on the point and that United Kingdom case law gives some support to his argument. It found it at least arguable that the issue can be considered despite the absence of a requisition.
The Director of Public Prosecutions remains free to argue at the hearing that the point should not be considered for that reason.