The Supreme Court has granted the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission leave to appeal directly from the High Court in a case brought by CRH Plc, Irish Cement Limited and Seamus Lynch. The determination was delivered on 27 June 2016.
The case arose from a search carried out by the Commission's authorised officers on 14 May 2015 at premises of Irish Cement in County Meath. The search was made under a District Court warrant issued under section 37 of the Competition and Consumer Protection Act 2014, as part of an investigation into the supply of bagged cement in the State.
CRH, Irish Cement and Mr Lynch took plenary proceedings in the High Court. Mr Justice Barrett gave judgment on 5 April 2016 and made an order on 26 April 2016. It declared that the Commission had acted outside the scope of the warrant and contrary to section 37 in seizing certain electronic documents from Mr Lynch's crh.com e-mail account. It also declared that accessing, reviewing or using them would breach his privacy rights under the European Convention on Human Rights and the Constitution. The Commission was restrained from accessing, reviewing or making any use of the documents.
The Commission asked the Supreme Court to hear its appeal without it first going to the Court of Appeal. This is known as a leapfrog appeal. It argued that the High Court had curtailed its powers to investigate suspected anti-competitive conduct and that the ruling could affect other bodies with similar search powers. It also said the delay could prejudice its investigation.
CRH, Irish Cement and Mr Lynch did not oppose the application for leave, though they did not accept all of the Commission's arguments.
The Supreme Court found that the case raised a matter of general public importance because it concerned legislation enacted as recently as 2014. It also found exceptional circumstances justified a direct appeal. It considered that, whatever the Court of Appeal decided, a further appeal to the Supreme Court was highly likely.
Leave was granted on all the grounds in the Commission's application. CRH, Irish Cement and Mr Lynch can still ask a Supreme Court judge managing the case to limit those grounds.
The Commission also sought a priority hearing. The court suggested it comply within seven days with paragraph 17 of the Chief Justice's practice direction and within one week with paragraph 19.