localnews.ie

Michael O'Shea careless driving death case goes to Supreme Court on DPP appeal

By Gráinne Nolan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Director of Public Prosecutions will argue the Court of Appeal applied the wrong test for careless driving causing death, an offence created in 2011.

The Supreme Court has granted the Director of Public Prosecutions leave to appeal in the case of Michael O'Shea, who was convicted of careless driving causing death. The determination was made on 17 June 2016.

Mr O'Shea was convicted at Naas Criminal Court on 12 November 2014. The offence is created by section 4 of the Road Traffic (No. 2) Act 2011. On 9 January 2013, he drove a car from a minor road towards roadworks at Graiguesallagh, Co Kildare. He collided with a JCB, and Kevin O'Sullivan, who was on traffic control duty, died.

The trial judge described the offence to the jury as one of "strict liability". On 15 December 2015, the Court of Appeal (Mahon J) held that this was incorrect and could have confused the jury. It ordered a retrial. The Director does not challenge that part of the judgment.

The Director wants to appeal on the question of what must be proved. She says the test for careless driving is an objective one. She says the Court of Appeal wrongly suggested a jury would have to find "intentional or reckless" driving. She says careless driving is one of the most commonly prosecuted summary offences in the State.

Mr O'Shea's side said the offence allows imprisonment of up to 2 years. It argued that this raises the question of whether intent must be proved.

The Supreme Court said the Court of Appeal's decision could have considerable ramifications for prosecutions of careless driving generally. It found the case raises a question of general public importance and that the interests of justice favour an appeal.

The issue is the ingredients of the offence under section 4 and what must be proved to sustain a conviction.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal