The Supreme Court has agreed to hear an appeal by the Minister for Justice and Equality, Ireland and the Attorney General against a Court of Appeal injunction that stopped a family being deported. It granted leave to appeal on 20 January 2016.
The respondents are a father, a mother and their two minor children, all Malawian nationals. Their asylum claims failed, as did later applications for subsidiary protection and leave to remain. Deportation orders were made against them in 2011. The family sought judicial review of those decisions. In the High Court on 19 April 2012, Justice Cooke refused leave to bring the case, holding that no stateable grounds existed for quashing the decisions. The family appealed.
The determination records that the family left their address, did not tell the authorities where they were and avoided deportation for several years. They presented again in 2015 and asked for an undertaking not to be deported. When that was refused, they went to the Court of Appeal.
On 27 July 2015 the Court of Appeal granted an injunction restraining deportation until their appeal is decided. It found they had a fair and arguable case and that the balance of convenience favoured an injunction. It said the parents' position alone would have little to commend it, given their evasion of immigration law. But it held the children were innocent of the parents' deceptions and had constitutional rights to the company and care of their parents.
The Minister, Ireland and the Attorney General said the Court of Appeal had misapplied and stretched the Supreme Court's earlier decision in Okunade, which dealt with injunctions before a High Court leave hearing. The family opposed leave, saying no point of general public importance arose.
The Supreme Court decided that an issue of general public importance did arise. That issue is the test to apply after a full High Court hearing has gone against the family, and whether the Okunade test is the right one. Leave was granted on two grounds, that the Court of Appeal erred in treating the Okunade test as applicable and erred in identifying the appropriate test. This was a decision on whether to hear the appeal. The appeal itself has not yet been decided.