The Supreme Court has granted Kilvinane Wind Farm Limited leave to appeal a Court of Appeal decision ordering three wind turbines in County Cork to be dismantled. It made the determination on 17 June 2016.
Two of the turbines were built with rotor diameters of 80 metres. The planning permission, granted on 19 July 2000, provided for rotor diameters of 57 metres. The third measures 58 metres, and each of the three was built between 19 and 20 metres from its original position.
William Henry Bailey, a litigant in person, brought the case under section 160 of the Planning and Development Act 2000. He wanted the turbines restrained, removed and the land restored. On 27 September 2013, Peart J in the High Court refused his application.
On 16 March 2016, the Court of Appeal (Finlay Geoghegan, Irvine and Hogan JJ) allowed Mr Bailey's appeal and set aside the High Court order. It ordered the turbines dismantled. That order is stayed until An Bord Pleanála decides the company's substitute consent application, and for eight weeks afterwards.
The company argued that the case raises two matters of general public importance. The first is how far a developer can deviate from a planning permission. The second is whether a developer can rely on statements from a planning authority approving such deviations. The Supreme Court agreed that both are of general public importance.
Leave is limited to two questions. The first asks what size of deviation crosses the materiality threshold and makes a development unauthorised. The second asks what difference it makes when a planning authority official tells a developer that a deviation is acceptable.
The Court did not accept the company's separate argument that the interests of justice required a review of the order to remove the turbines as disproportionate. It said the company had not shown that it had jurisdiction to review the Court of Appeal's conclusion on relief.
The Court has not formed a view on the company's proposal to put further evidence before it.