localnews.ie

Sea Fisheries Protection Authority granted Supreme Court appeal in Crayden case

By Donal Gilhooly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The State will appeal directly from a High Court ruling that 12 penalty points imposed on a fishing vessel's licence breached fair procedures.

The Supreme Court has granted the Sea Fisheries Protection Authority, the Minister for the Marine, Ireland, the Attorney General and Michael O'Connor leave to appeal directly from the High Court. The determination was made on 10 June 2016.

The case was brought by Crayden Fishing Company Limited, which operates the fishing vessel Anders Nees. It is said that in December 2014 a large quantity of fish was found in a compartment on the vessel that was not recorded in the electronic logbook. Crayden was told by letter of 19 January 2015 that 12 points would be imposed under the European Union (Common Fisheries Policy) (Points System) Regulations 2014.

Crayden brought a judicial review. On 26 January 2016, O'Malley J held that the way points were assigned to its licence was contrary to fair procedures. The State is appealing the whole of that order.

Crayden did not oppose leave, and the Supreme Court said that was the right approach. The Court found the issues potentially of general public importance, because the Regulations applied across a range of cases and were adopted to meet Ireland's obligations under EU fisheries law. It said that an appeal from the Court of Appeal would "look the same" as a direct one, so skipping that step lost little.

One qualification is that the Regulations have since been replaced by new 2016 Regulations. The Court said this reduced both the urgency and, to some extent, the general importance of the case. It still saw considerable merit in settling quickly how Ireland may comply with EU law.

The State's grounds, which may be refined, are that the judge was wrong to find a breach of fair procedures, and wrong to treat a licence holder's economic circumstances as relevant to whether there was a serious infringement.

The Court ordered the State to file its notice of intention to proceed within ten days. It will hear this case and the O'Sullivan appeal at a joint first case management hearing before the same judge.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal