The Supreme Court has granted Caroline McNamee leave to appeal. The decision was delivered on 10 June 2016.
Ms McNamee sued Michael Boyce for damages. Her claim was for alleged sexual and other assault and false imprisonment between 1979 and 1992. Mr Boyce asked the High Court to dismiss the claim for delay. His grounds included prejudice from the death of Helen Boyce. The application failed, and he renewed it at trial.
The trial was before O'Malley J and a jury in November 2012. It lasted six days. The judge rejected his applications to dismiss. The jury found that Mr Boyce had sexually assaulted Ms McNamee between 1979 and 1985. It awarded just under €500,000.
Mr Boyce appealed. On 4 February 2016, the Court of Appeal allowed his appeal. Its judges were Finlay Geoghegan, Peart and Irvine JJ. It found the trial judge had erred on where the "balance of justice" lay. It held the claim should have been dismissed for inordinate and inexcusable delay. It set aside the award and ordered costs against Ms McNamee.
The Supreme Court said issues of general public importance arise. One is how far an appeal court may interfere with a trial judge's ruling on delay. Another is how much weight a defendant's own contribution to delay should carry. The Court noted that the second issue may engage the European Convention on Human Rights.
Leave is granted on three grounds. They may be refined in case management. The first asks whether a ruling on dismissal for delay is a true exercise of discretion. The second asks how far an appeal court should defer to the trial judge's balancing.
The third concerns a defendant who did not use available procedures to speed up the case. It asks what weight that should carry.