The Supreme Court has refused Breifne O'Brien leave to appeal against a Court of Appeal judgment on his sentence. The decision was delivered on 10 June 2016.
On 18 June 2014, Mr O'Brien pleaded guilty to seven counts of deception and seven counts of theft. On 8 October 2015, he was sentenced to concurrent terms of three and a half years and seven years. The shorter term was for deception and the longer for theft.
The Court of Appeal (Birmingham, Sheehan and Edwards JJ) dismissed his appeal on 21 December 2015. It held that rehabilitation was a matter of mitigation and did not need separate treatment, such as a partly suspended sentence. It found the sentence substantial but correct given the seriousness of the offence.
Mr O'Brien said that ruling set a principle of general public importance. The Supreme Court disagreed. It said the weight given to rehabilitation depends on the facts of each case, and that a sentencing judge has a significant margin of appreciation. It said the Court of Appeal's ruling did not stop a partly suspended sentence being used in other cases.
The Court said no issue of general public importance arose. It did not need to decide whether to extend the time for his application.