The Supreme Court has granted the Sea Fisheries Protection Authority, the Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine, Ireland and the Attorney General leave to appeal directly from the High Court. It made the determination on 10 June 2016.
The case was brought by Patrick O'Sullivan and Cathal O'Sullivan. It concerns the European Union (Common Policy) (Points System) Regulations 2014. The O'Sullivans argued that parts of the Regulations went beyond the principles and policies of EU fisheries law.
In a judgment delivered on 15 January 2016, O'Connor J agreed. He held the Regulations were ultra vires section 3 of the European Communities Act 1972, and so invalid under Article 15.2.1 of the Constitution. The State is appealing that whole decision.
The Regulations were revoked and replaced between the judgment and the court order. The O'Sullivans said that made the appeal moot. The Supreme Court did not find that point clear enough to be decisive, and leave is without prejudice to either side arguing it at the hearing.
The Court said the case raises a point of law of general public importance. Skipping the Court of Appeal would add little, it said, because the benefit of an intermediate appeal in refining the issues is "limited at best". It also said Ireland must be certain how it may comply with EU law.
The Court granted leave in a separate case, Crayden Fishing Company Ltd, the same day. Both cases challenge the Regulations. The State must file its notice of intention to proceed within ten days, and the first case management hearing for both appeals will be before the same judge at the same time.
The State's grounds, which may be refined, are that the judge was wrong on whether the Regulations were necessitated by EU law, wrong to find them invalid, and failed to assume that the Regulations' procedures would be operated fairly.